Permalink to Committee and Judges eligibility

Committee and Judges eligibility

Last week, an interview with BCB radio prompted a discussion among the committee about eligibility that we’ve chewed over for a few days.

See, we’d all implicitly agreed that none of the committee members or judges would have nominated work (it always looks a bit cheeky, to be honest) but we hadn’t ever written it down.

Correcting that was easy. No works created in whole or mainly by a member of the judging panel or committee will be eligible for a BCA nomination.

But what about anthologies?

As an editor of one myself (Paper Science) I’d assumed that it would be ‘my’ work, and would fall under the rule above. But other anthologies published in the past year feature very small stories by creators either on the committee or that we’re approaching to be judges. And when that might mean they’ve contributed 3 pages out of 150 or so, something didn’t seem quite right.

So we’ve settled on another one. No anthologies edited or curated by a member of the judging panel or committee will be eligible for a BCA nomination.

It seems the fairest way to halt any accusations of nepotism while also being open to the huge variety of anthologies produced by our tight-knit comics community here on Blighty.

Obviously we’ll see how that works out as time goes on; the ‘rules’ about nominations will have to evolve over time, as new ways of producing comics develop and surprise us.

We’ll be as open as we can be about that – without spoiling the nominations – right here.

Matthew Sheret.


Call for Entries

The Call for Entries for the 4th Annual British Comic Awards is now OPEN!

Visit our Entry Form to submit your favourite comic or your own work!

BCA Twitter

In Association With

Page 45 is an award-winning comic shop whose goal has always been simple: to bring the widest range of quality comics and graphic novels available into contact with as many new people as possible, and to do so with a warmth, honesty and informed eloquence in a relaxed, welcoming and professional environment.

Host Festival

Thought Bubble is the UK's largest annual event which celebrates sequential art in all its forms, including everything from superheroes to independent and small press comics. They are an non-profit organisation dedicated to promoting comics and graphic novels as an important cultural art form. Taking place at a variety of venues across the city of Leeds, our aim is to cater to both long-term comic book fans and those who have never picked up a graphic novel before!

Our Sponsors